Do You Need a Comedy Class to Start Stand-Up in NYC?

By Adam Malev ·

No. You do not need a comedy class to start doing stand-up in New York. You need five minutes of material and an open mic, and there are 418 of those listed in this city with 128 of them free.

That is the short answer, and most people selling classes will not give it to you.

The longer answer is that classes do some things well, cost real money, and get recommended by people who have an obvious interest in you taking one. Here is what they actually do.

What NYC comedy classes cost

Prices in New York run roughly from 150 to 475 dollars.

Brooklyn Comedy Collective runs stand-up intensives around 150 dollars. UCB and The PIT have historically charged in the range of 175 dollars for four weeks and 325 for eight. NYC Comedy Class advertises around 475 dollars for four sessions. There are six-week beginner courses around 395 dollars that include a graduation show at a Manhattan club and a video of your set.

The American Comedy Institute and Manhattan Comedy School sit at the more serious end, aimed at people who already know they want to pursue this.

So you are looking at somewhere between the cost of a nice dinner and the cost of a month's phone bill plus a bit, depending on where you go.

What a comedy class genuinely gives you

A deadline and a room full of people in the same position. This is the real product. Most people who say they want to try stand-up never do, because the first open mic is terrifying and nothing forces you to go. A class makes you write by Tuesday and perform in front of eleven people who are equally nervous.

Feedback from someone who knows what they are doing. At an open mic nobody tells you why a joke did not land. In a class, somebody does.

A graduation show. Most courses end with a performance at a real club in front of a real audience, which is a very different experience from an open mic room full of comics. For a lot of people that night is the whole reason to do it.

Structure for joke writing. Setup, punchline, tags, act outs. You can learn this from books and watching, but having it explained in order saves time.

What a comedy class cannot give you

Stage time. This is the big one. A six-week course might put you on stage twice. Doing three open mics a week for those same six weeks is eighteen sets. Nothing substitutes for reps, and the class is not where you get them.

A booking. No class gets you booked. Schools attached to clubs sometimes imply a pipeline. Treat that carefully.

A voice. Classes teach structure. Finding what is actually funny about you takes years and happens on stage, not in a classroom.

When a comedy class makes sense

If you have been saying you want to try stand-up for two years and have not done it, buy the deadline. It is worth 300 dollars to stop talking about it.

If you are genuinely terrified of the first mic, a class gives you a softer first performance in front of people who are also bad at this.

If you want a decent video of yourself on a club stage, the graduation show produces one.

If you are not sure you will even like it, a short cheap course is a reasonable way to find out before rearranging your week around open mics.

When it does not

If you are already going to open mics, a class is mostly redundant. You are getting more reps than it would give you.

If money is tight, spend nothing. 128 free mics is more stage time than any class provides, and it costs you subway fare.

If someone at a mic is pushing you toward their class, be careful. Some rooms exist partly to funnel new comics into paid courses and bringer shows.

Frequently asked questions

Do you need a comedy class to do stand-up?

No. Anyone can sign up at an open mic without training or experience. Classes are optional and mainly useful for structure, feedback and a deadline.

How much do stand-up comedy classes cost in NYC?

Roughly 150 to 475 dollars. Shorter intensives sit at the lower end, and multi-week beginner courses with a graduation show sit at the higher end.

Are comedy classes worth it for beginners?

They are worth it if you need a deadline, want feedback, or are too nervous to start alone. They are not worth it if you are already doing open mics, because they give far less stage time than you are already getting.

Can a comedy class get you booked on shows?

No. Bookings come from open mics, producing your own shows and knowing people in the scene. No class guarantees paid work, and you should be sceptical of any that implies it.

What is better, a comedy class or open mics?

Open mics, for stage time. A six-week class might give you two performances. Three mics a week over the same period gives you eighteen. Use a class for structure, use mics for reps.

Where can I do stand-up in NYC for free?

There are 128 free open mics listed across New York, running every night of the week, with the most on Wednesdays. No sign-up fee and no class required.

Start with a free room

You can browse every free open mic in New York, or see all open mics by borough and night.

If you are new, start with the beginner-friendly rooms or a Wednesday.

All posts